Montana PBS Reports: IMPACT
Rural Water / Corner Crossing
Season 5 Episode 3 | 26m 33sVideo has Closed Captions
Towns pipe in their drinking water, Plus, a thorny debate over access to public land.
A regional water authority in central MT is piping drinking water hundreds of miles across the state. Plus, the debate over “corner crossing” puts public access and private property rights in tension.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Montana PBS Reports: IMPACT is a local public television program presented by Montana PBS
Production funding for IMPACT is provided by the Greater Montana Foundation, encouraging communication on issues, trends and values of importance to Montanans; and by the Friends of Montana PBS.
Montana PBS Reports: IMPACT
Rural Water / Corner Crossing
Season 5 Episode 3 | 26m 33sVideo has Closed Captions
A regional water authority in central MT is piping drinking water hundreds of miles across the state. Plus, the debate over “corner crossing” puts public access and private property rights in tension.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Montana PBS Reports: IMPACT
Montana PBS Reports: IMPACT is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship- [Stan] Next on "Impact."
Communities across Central and Eastern Montana struggle with water.
Some have found success in a regional solution, pipeline systems hundreds of miles long.
- We're pretty lucky we found this water, I think.
- Plus, in an effort to unlock public lands, a Bozeman lawmaker says it's time to make corner crossing legal in Montana.
- Just the idea that I can't move, like, a checker to get over there to what is our land is kind of crazy to me.
- And why many landowners disagree.
- It takes away my ability to manage our ranch.
- Coming to you from the campuses of Montana State University, Bozeman, and the University of Montana, Missoula, you're watching "Impact" from Montana PBS Reports.
And those stories are straight ahead.
Stay with us.
- [Narrator] Major funding for "Impact" comes from the Greater Montana Foundation, encouraging communication on issues, trends, and values of importance to Montanans.
Funding also comes from viewers like you, who are friends of Montana PBS.
Thank you.
"Impact" is an editorially independent production of Montana PBS Reports.
Coverage decisions are made by our team of Montana-based journalists.
For feedback, questions or ideas, email us, impact@montanapbs.org.
- Welcome to "Impact."
I'm Stan Parker.
Water quantity and quality issues have dogged some Montana communities for decades.
In some places, the water is undrinkable.
In others, they run out of it.
And in some places, it's both.
The problem only gets worse with drought and aging infrastructure.
Reporter Sam Wilson has been looking into this issue and what some of these small towns are doing about it.
Sam, what have you found?
- Well, communities have been looking regionally, working together to find better sources of water elsewhere, sometimes hundreds of miles away, and pipe them home.
These are projects that take decades to complete in the best case and rely heavily on federal dollars.
But for people who benefit from these huge infrastructure projects, the results are worth it.
At the Back Porch restaurant in Roundup, a cup of coffee will set you back $2.50.
It's a good deal for a good cup of coffee anywhere, but even more so if you know something about the history of water in Roundup.
- Now, when we were kids, getting a drink out of the hose was common stuff.
It was good cold water, loved it.
Quench your thirst.
We never even give it a thought.
I know the public works director always told me that it was getting worse.
- Kind of a big deal locally was water heaters that just, you know, people put in a water heater, I don't know what the normal life is, should be 10 years probably, but a lot of them are coming back out in two years, because I think it was high iron content plus whatever else.
- The big thing is that if you made coffee at home with that old water, it put a scum on the top of the cup of coffee.
And most people take a napkin or something and wipe it off before they drink it.
That ain't how it works now.
- [Sam] How it works now looks like this.
Cold, clean water from a deep well field near Judith Gap is piped to Roundup and a handful of other communities along the way.
It's a massive improvement from the abandoned coal mine they used to get their water from, but it comes at a great expense.
Over $100 million and 25 years of organizing and planning.
- In many Eastern Montana communities, the existing public water supplies are not drinkable because they are highly saline, they have a lot of naturally occurring minerals, and in some cases, have been contaminated by industry, whether that's agriculture or, in some cases, oil and gas.
And these are things that people have been living with for decades and have organized systems to cope with.
But if you were a newcomer arriving in that place, it would really demand a big change in how you operated around everyday things, including getting in your shower and seeing the whole interior of the shower being brown, things that would just, I think, be really jarring.
And that's not to say these aren't beautiful, healthy places to live, but the public water systems are really inadequate.
- Every survey that was done in Roundup, in all the years I've been around, the number one issue is bad water.
- [Sam] Monty Sealey grew up in Roundup and worked for the Montana Department of Natural Resources.
He says the town looked into treating the water from that old coal mine.
- The estimated cost at that time, as I recall, to put in a water treatment facility, not counting all the environmental problems you'd have to deal with, was somewhere around $15 million.
And we just said, "No, there's other ways.
Let's see if we can get around with these other towns, and if they got bad water, maybe they're interested in grouping up."
And that's what ended up happening.
- [Sam] The group organized into what would become the Central Montana Regional Water Authority.
Using money from the Montana Coal Trust, they drilled the test well 3,700 feet deep near Judith Gap in 2003 into an aquifer far deeper than where ranchers and other water users were sourcing.
The location had two big advantages.
It was way up at 4,200 feet in elevation, so the system could be gravity-fed, and the water was clean.
- The fact you don't have pumping systems and you don't have a treatment system.
We're pretty lucky we found this water, I think.
- [Sam] Water from the well field is already flowing to Harlowton, Roundup, and Melstone.
It'll connect to Broadview in 2027, and by the time it connects to Hobson in 2028 or '29, it'll stretch 230 miles, connecting towns as well as individual rural households.
- It's serving, at this point in time, by census estimates, 5,000 people.
We've got room to service 7,300.
We've got that growth built into it, 1% a year growth.
- [Sam] Three other water projects in Eastern Montana are in various stages of completion, covering even larger regions.
Each of these projects will be pumping and treating water from reservoirs, which makes them much more expensive.
- In order to bring drinking water systems up to standards, there is lots of public support in the form of state and federal programs.
Accessing those supports and, again, stacking them in the right order so that you can get the work done, requires an almost Herculean kind of commitment.
- All in favor, raise your right hand.
- [Sam] Every second Wednesday of the month at 1:00 PM, that Herculean commitment is on full display at the Harlowton Public Library, where the board of the Central Montana Project meets.
- Roundup and Harlowton each have two board members because of their population, and then each other town gets one.
That's our board.
They've been meeting since 2005.
We've had some people stayed a long time, some kind of come and go, mayors come and go.
But you got to understand that that amount of volunteerism in people from this area is what kept it rolling.
- [Sam] The board struggled to get traction for a while, bouncing between the requirements of federal and state agencies, and while the project had bipartisan support from the Montana congressional delegation, it was easily derailed by national politics.
In 2017, Sealey, along with engineer Bob Church and board member Jeff Sell, traveled to Washington, D.C., to testify on the project, but they never got the opportunity.
The day before the hearing, Donald Trump fired James Comey as FBI director.
Senator Steve Daines had brought water samples from Montana to the Senate floor, but Senate Democrats objected to the discussion in protest of Comey's firing.
- If you're looking for sustained and viable support for big infrastructure projects, you probably don't want to be subjecting yourself to the machinations of Congress right now.
- [Sam] In 2020, Congress finally authorized construction on the project.
The total cost for finishing the work will be $135 million, split three ways.
The federal government is footing nearly $88 million, the state is at $23.5 million, and another $23.5 million will be paid by ratepayers at an average of $45 a month.
- There's debates about whether the feds should be spending that money and all this thing with the 40 million, 40 billion, trillion-dollar deficit.
Well, I'm sure the money they put in here went on the deficit because they had to borrow it.
But one thing about it, it's benefiting citizens.
$22,000 per capita is the government money in this thing.
Now, is that a good deal or not?
I don't know.
But I paid more than that in income taxes last year myself.
So I think I could use that water still and not feel bad about it.
- [Sam] But not all communities in need are benefiting from vast public dollars being spent on regional water systems.
This past spring, the town of Fairfield declared a water supply emergency, enacting a water use restriction that left the public school temporarily using porta-potties.
Fairfield's water system relies entirely on irrigation canals recharging their aquifer.
- After the canals shut off, we start depleting the system.
It starts dropping slowly, we hope.
(chuckles) Last year dropped faster than we wanted to.
Until we can find another source of water, that's what we have.
And it's not just finding a source of water.
There's places we can go to find it.
It's also getting the water rights to use that source plus the infrastructure to get it here.
- [Sam] Unlike Roundup, Fairfield doesn't have an issue with water quality.
Theirs is a problem of quantity.
The town spent millions of dollars this summer drilling four new wells.
- And none of them were gonna produce what we need at all.
I won't call them a dry hole because technically they weren't.
There was a little bit of water there, but it wasn't enough to do us any good.
- [Sam] The situation has gotten so bad that the town no longer allows new water users on their system.
- Housing here is tight all the time and crazy expensive, but there is an appetite for growth here, but like I say, we can't.
We don't have the water.
We don't do taps anymore.
There's a moratorium basically on it.
So we will not add any more to the system until we get a more reliable source.
- [Sam] For now, no regional systems include Fairfield.
- Ideally, my personal opinion is I'd like it to stay as local as we could get it, because that way, we have more control over it.
But if you can't, you have to do what you have to do.
If you live here, it's worth everything.
I've traveled all over and been in a lot of places.
This is a community I chose to live in.
There's a reason for it.
There's a reason Fairfield looks like what Fairfield is, and we'd like to keep it that way, but (chuckles) without it, what do you do?
- There are some fundamental services that people need to survive.
Clean drinking water is one of them.
It's a sustainable development goal of the UN.
So the idea that we have communities in Montana that might be like what our imagination is of some developing world context where there isn't reliable access to clean drinking water, I think is a really important observation.
There's a huge sense of pride of what's been contributed to national economies.
We provided light for the cities in the Midwest.
We provided electricity for manufacturing on the West Coast.
We provide clean, great sources of food and fiber to consumers, not only in America, but across the world.
There is missing in our national political dialogue what our commitment to rural places is.
In the absence of that, you can imagine that rural places that are trying to get things done very much see themselves as alone in these challenges and having to cobble together resources from wherever they can get them.
- [Sam] Back in Roundup, Sealey gave me a tour around town, showing me where the first new neighborhood in decades was being constructed, and his office overflowing with hard copies of engineering diagrams.
- That's all feasibility study for this thing.
- [Sam] Our last stop was at the Arcade Bar, which is where the vision for the Central Montana Regional Water Project began.
- People don't believe in little towns that projects like this can happen.
We all needed it, and so now we all got it.
So again, thanks, man.
- Yeah.
Thanks to you, Monty.
For "Impact," I'm Sam Wilson.
- Montana's congressional delegation has been pushing to authorize construction of the state's fourth regional water project, the Dry-Redwater system in Eastern Montana.
That project plans to put in 1,300 miles of pipe, over five times larger than the Central Montana water system.
Montana's checkerboard landscape has posed a problematic legal question for both hunters and landowners for decades.
Is it legal to cross onto public land over a property corner?
Montana PBS's Matt Standal has been looking into this issue just in time for hunting season.
Matt, why are we seeing this debate ramp up in 2026?
- Yeah, Stan, the problem with corner crossing here in Montana is that there's no state law that specifically talks about the issue, and it's also such a gray area that the state's game wardens have not been authorized to issue tickets over it until a major FWP policy decision this spring.
However, a Bozeman lawmaker says it's time to clear up the confusion about corners, and he's going toe to toe with both the governor's office and landowners who say corners are not meant for crossing.
It's the first snow of the year, and Josh Seckinger is out hunting with his good buddy, Shawn Swain, on a piece of public land in Southwest Montana.
- West of Bozeman, south of Three Forks.
The Madison River is about a mile and a half from us, a mile and a half away here, down in the clouds over there.
- [Matt] Seckinger is a local fishing guide and serves as a state representative in the Montana Legislature.
- These laws... - [Matt] Swain is a professional musician and plays with the Kitchen Dwellers, a popular jam band based in Bozeman.
- She's having a blast.
- [Matt] It's also the season's first outing for Kestrel, Swain's bird dog, who, despite her excitement, is having a hard time running through the deep snow.
- I might have to send you guys.
- That's fine.
- 'Cause she's already... I can tell her feet are hurting.
- See, this is where having a dog comes in handy.
(chuckles) - [Matt] Down a hunting buddy and down a dog, Seckinger soldiers on to find the reason he's invited me on this fall bird hunting trip in the first place.
We're here to talk about the controversial topic of corner crossing.
- We just walked over a mile to get here on this piece of public land, and behind us over here is another piece of public land.
We are not allowed to go from here to there legally.
I think it's time we fix that.
- [Matt] Zooming out, the section of public land we're on is owned by the state of Montana and meets another section of state land at a common corner.
The only problem, it also meets two sections of private land, kind of like the squares on a checkerboard.
- Just the idea that I can't move like a checker in checkers to get over there to what is our land is kind of crazy to me.
- So I'd like to explain to you today the current status of corner crossings in Montana.
- [Matt] Montana's lieutenant governor gave her analysis of the issue earlier this spring, saying corner crossing has never been legal in Montana, and state game wardens are authorized to write tickets to hunters caught doing so, even if they just briefly pass through the airspace above private land.
- We have Montana Supreme Court decisions saying that if you come into my airspace, that's a trespass.
- [Matt] Across the state of Montana, more than 1.5 million acres of public land is landlocked and surrounded by private property.
Of that 1.5 million acres, more than 870,000 are what's known as corner-locked and often form a checkerboard landscape where sections of public land alternate with sections of private land that effectively lock them up due to the state's strict stance on trespassing.
Montana's checkerboard lands include federal wilderness, national forest, BLM, state and private property, a byproduct of the railroad land grants of the 1800s and a legacy of the Homestead Act.
Proponents of corner crossing hope to unlock much of this checkerboard land, a move that has recently found hunters and landowners facing off in court.
- [Sheriff] Since you witnessed it and everything, criminal trespass can be harder to gauge than corner crossing.
- [Matt] In 2022, a Wyoming rancher sued a group of hunters after they crossed a corner to access public land inside his ranch.
The case eventually made its way through the federal courts, and the hunters won on appeal.
But that decision doesn't apply here in Montana, and that's because Montana and Wyoming answer to different federal appeals courts.
- Corner crossing's trespassing.
It's a violation of my private property rights.
It takes away my ability to manage our ranch.
- [Matt] Here in the Ruby Valley, rancher Rick Sandru says hunters have obviously heard the news out of Wyoming and have been trying to corner cross on his property, testing whether game wardens will issue tickets or not.
- The warden doesn't do anything because it's a waste of his time.
He's already stretched too thin, and so he's not gonna mess around with it because it won't be prosecuted.
- [Matt] Sandru ranches just outside of Twin Bridges, Montana, and runs a cow-calf operation east of the Jefferson River.
His land includes prime habitat for just about every big game animal in Montana, but unlike some landowners in the state, Sandru does not sell hunts or charge for access.
He says locals here in the Ruby Valley know they need to ask permission to hunt his land, and those who get to know his family and ask politely usually get that opportunity.
- You know, there's usually somebody recreating on our property every day.
Last year harvested 20 elk on our property, 50 deer, I don't know how many pheasants and geese.
- [Matt] Here in the bench country that slopes down from the Tobacco Root Mountains, Sandru shows me where the corner crossers have been walking onto his property from nearby state land.
He says hunters trying to cross here have trespassed on at least three occasions and wonders how anyone would drag an elk or a deer over his fence without causing some type of damage.
- I've seen a corner cross before and they don't cross the corner.
I mean, you're gonna hop over that corner?
They come to that corner and they run down the fence and they crawl through where they can get through.
You can't cross over that corner easily.
So the corner crossing is kind of an illusion.
- Yeah, there's no state statute that dictates, you know, legality or illegality of corner crossing, and so it was always a bit of a gray area.
- [Matt] Mike Volesky is a former operations director at the Montana Department of Fish, Wildlife Parks, and served under the Bullock administration.
His tenure ended under contentious circumstances.
He claimed that he was fired for political reasons in 2024, allegations state government officials deny.
before that,Voleskey had spent 20 years in state government.
- The law was never clear on corner crossing, and prosecutors across Montana, county attorneys across Montana, typically just were reluctant to take those cases.
- [Matt] Volesky says for decades, the FWP told wardens not to issue tickets for corner crossing because county prosecutors wouldn't press charges.
Volesky points to these department memos from 2001 and 2018 outlining the FWP's legal opinion on the matter, an opinion that states there is no Montana law directly addressing corner crossings.
The memos take the position that corner crossing is trespassing, but that wardens should not issue tickets until there's either an attorney general's opinion or legislation to address it.
that all changed in January of 2026, when the department authorized wardens to start writing tickets for corner crossing So, the administration here is attempting to to make up new law out of whole cloth backed by no legislative authority [Matt] Volesky has publicly criticized the agency for this.
The FWP confirmed the policy change to us, but referred further questions to the governor’s office.
Officials there did not respond to our calls or emails.
- I think it is an unsettled issue.
I'm trying to settle it to affirm the legality of the public to access their land.
- [Matt] Representative Seckinger showed me this draft bill he hopes will clear up the matter and legalize corner crossing in Montana.
Seckinger plans to float the bill during the upcoming '27 legislative session and says that lawmakers on both sides of the aisle support the cause.
- Polling shows that the public is overwhelmingly in favor of corner crossing.
- [Matt] But are private landowners in favor of it?
Seckinger helped author a previous bill during the 2025 session to give payments to landowners to voluntarily allow corner crossing, a program he says hasn't had any takers yet.
And nobody signed up?
- No.
- [Matt] Why?
- It's a great question and I don't have the answer.
- [Matt] In June, FWP's Private Land/Public Wildlife Advisory Committee met over the course of two days in Glasgow to discuss what they hoped could be a separate effort, an official FWP corner crossing pilot program with the goal of finding at least one landowner to participate, although by November's hunting season, that effort also turned up short.
- If something passes where it's legal to corner cross, I'm afraid that hunters are gonna find a lot more land locked up and a lot more land taken out of block management.
That's just a slap in the face to the landowners that are stewarding these lands.
- [Matt] Sandru says he is not interested in any government program or new law that could take away a landowner's property rights.
And he says Montana ranchers are likely to clamp down on public access to prevent more cases of trespassing if efforts to legalize corner crossing go through.
- I think people need to really think this through.
You might not like what you're wishing for here.
- It's not your land.
It's our land.
It's everybody's land.
- [Matt] But for Representative Josh Seckinger, public ownership also means public responsibility.
He says all hunters need to be fully accountable for their actions no matter what side of the fence they're on.
- Trespassing is trespassing.
Hunting without landowner permission is hunting without landowner permission.
Corner crossing should be neither of those.
It is the public accessing the public land.
Now, if you mess up, I hope a county prosecutor will prosecute that.
And if you're clearly hunting someone else's land, you should be prosecuted for that.
- [Matt] In Bozeman, I'm Matt Standal for "Impact."
- Advocates for and against corner crossing say things could be cleared up by a new law, new court decision, or attorney general's opinion.
There's also a lawsuit underway brought by outdoor recreation groups that seek to legalize corner crossing through the court system.
Well, that's all we have for you on this episode of "Impact."
You can find all our previous episodes on our website or on the PBS app for your phone or smart TV.
For questions, feedback, or story ideas, send us an email, impact@montanapbs.org.
I'm Stan Parker.
From all of us here at Montana PBS, thank you for watching.
(upbeat music) (upbeat music continues) (upbeat music continues) - [Narrator] Major funding for "Impact" comes from the Greater Montana Foundation, encouraging communication on issues, trends, and values of importance to Montanans.
Funding also comes from viewers like you, who are friends of Montana PBS.
Thank you.
(gentle music)
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.

- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.



New Episode

New Episode


New Episode
Support for PBS provided by:
Montana PBS Reports: IMPACT is a local public television program presented by Montana PBS
Production funding for IMPACT is provided by the Greater Montana Foundation, encouraging communication on issues, trends and values of importance to Montanans; and by the Friends of Montana PBS.