Montana Ag Live
Rangeland in Montana
Season 6600 Episode 10 | 56m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
Montana's rangeland provides livestock forage, wildlife habitat, recreation and more.
Montana is home to millions of rangeland acres. They provide forage for the state's ranching industry, habitat for wildlife, outdoor recreation, and even carbon capture. This week, we welcome Georgia Harrison, Range Ecologist at MSU to enlighten us about this unique and valuable ecosystem.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Montana Ag Live is a local public television program presented by Montana PBS
The Montana Department of Agriculture, the MSU Extension Service, the MSU AG Experiment Stations of the College of Agriculture, the Montana Wheat & Barley Committee, Cashman Nursery and Landscaping, Gallatin Gardeners Club, and the Montana Foundation of Garden Clubs.
Montana Ag Live
Rangeland in Montana
Season 6600 Episode 10 | 56m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
Montana is home to millions of rangeland acres. They provide forage for the state's ranching industry, habitat for wildlife, outdoor recreation, and even carbon capture. This week, we welcome Georgia Harrison, Range Ecologist at MSU to enlighten us about this unique and valuable ecosystem.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Montana Ag Live
Montana Ag Live is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship- [Narrator] "Montana Ag Live" is made possible by the Montana Department of Agriculture, MSU Extension, the MSU Ag Experiment Station of the College of Agriculture, the Montana Wheat & Barley Committee, Cashman Nursery & Landscaping, the Gallatin Gardeners Club, and the Montana Federation of Garden Clubs.
(upbeat country music) - Good evening and welcome to "Montana Ag Live", coming to you from the KUSM studio on the vibrant campus of Montana State University in Bozeman, and coming to you over your Montana public broadcasting system.
I'm Jane Mangold.
I'm sitting in tonight for Jack Riesselman.
Jack, if you're watching, I hope you're enjoying some good food and an adult beverage this Sunday evening.
We have a great show, as always, lined up for you this evening.
This evening, we're going to be talking about rangelands.
So rangelands cover about 70% of Montana and provide a lot of ecosystem services, recreation, support our livestock industry.
So let me go ahead and introduce our panel.
We will be talking about rangeland, but we have a panel here that has a lot of great people with expertise across a variety of topics.
On the far right of our panel is Sam Wyffels.
Sam is the Extension beef cattle specialist.
Sitting next to Sam is our special guest tonight, Georgia Harrison.
Georgia is an Assistant Professor of Rangeland Ecology in the Department of Animal and Range Sciences.
Sitting in the middle is Eric Belasco, ag economist.
And sitting to my right, my left, your right for you viewers, is Nina Zidack.
Nina is a plant pathologist and horticulture expert.
She is retired, but she's happy to answer questions about potatoes.
- Yes, absolutely.
Always want to talk about potatoes.
- Always want to talk about potatoes or any of your lawn and garden questions.
And then answering the phones for us tonight are Nancy Blake and Sherry Class.
I do want to mention that tonight is our final show for the fall season.
So if you've had a burning question and have not had time to get it into the show, this is your opportunity.
I'd like to go back to our special guest, Georgia Harrison.
Georgia, please tell us a little bit about yourself and what kind of work you do on Montana rangeland.
- Thanks, Jane, thanks for having me.
Yeah, so I'm a new assistant professor here at MSU.
I primarily research how plants in rangelands change over time and space.
So I use field information, going out and doing plant surveys to measure how plants grow together and how they respond to changes.
And then I also do a lot using satellite-based data to assess how plants and rangelands grow over space and time.
Yeah.
- Georgia, I'm wondering, we could have some viewers who don't really know what rangeland is.
Do you want to take a stab at defining what rangeland is?
- Yes, I think the most broad and all-encompassing way to define them is areas that are free of ice and generally free of trees.
- [Jane] Yeah.
- So mostly grass and shrubland systems, but could include, there's still water, there's still riparian in other areas.
- It's funny.
I've heard rangeland defined by what it isn't, which is kind of, I don't know, sometimes I feel like that's not.
- It's a big space.
- Very fair for rangeland.
- Yeah.
- But yeah, it's not crop, not cities, not forest.
- But weeds.
- Well, there are weeds on rangeland is where I spend my time.
- That's right.
- Georgia's done some work with weeds too, which hopefully we'll get a chance to talk about tonight.
All right, well, thanks Georgia for being here.
We're going to go right to Sam to get us going tonight.
- [Sam] Oh, great, yeah.
(group laughs) - Sam, this question came in from Miles City.
We're wrapping up fall and kind of moving into colder time of the year.
What are producers doing to graze longer, maybe into the winter, and feed less hay?
- Yeah, so it's pretty common, or I guess most people agree that one of the biggest inputs into a beef cattle system is feed and feed requirements.
I'm sure Eric would agree with that.
That's where our number one place is.
And so there's always a place to try to, how do we navigate that?
How do we minimize or optimize that to where we meet these animals' nutrient requirements, but maybe reduce some of these forage inputs?
And so this time of year is really interesting.
So when we wean calves off of our cows, the cows then dry up, they're no longer lactating, and they're at their most modest nutrient requirements at that point in time.
So a lot of producers will actually kick those animals back out on range or pasture and allow them to graze.
Now, there's a good chance that forage isn't meeting their nutrient requirements fully, but by providing some modest protein supplementation, we can actually optimize the use of those pretty well.
With other tools, if we're into stringing out some electric fence or virtual fence is a big topic these days, there's a lot of things of like crop livestock integration systems that are also becoming a little more popular.
And so I'm sure a lot of folks have heard of cover crops and the importance or the benefits that cover crops can play in an agronomic system.
They can also be a fantastic forage for livestock, especially this time of year.
And so grazing crop lands, grazing available forage that is standing at this point in time, anything we can do to extend the grazing season can help us reduce reliance on those harvested forages.
I just always like to throw out there, there's a good chance you might need to add some supplement to make sure we're meeting those requirements, though.
- Sam, is there anything producers should be doing now to kind of prepare for calving in the spring, right?
- Yeah, absolutely.
So I always try to tell folks in my talks or even students in my class that because we're at our modest nutrient requirements of these animals right now, like that, you know, a lot of guys are starting to wean October, some folks are just finishing weaning now, that's our best time to put condition on animals with the least amount of inputs.
And so for instance, a lot of our cattle, once they are done lactating or they've dried up are sitting at like a crude protein requirement of somewhere around 8% crude protein.
So even feeding like a lower crude protein hay at this point in time, something that's in like that 10% range can actually help improve those cattle condition.
Too often I wait, I see you guys wait till like January where you're about like two months out from calving to say, "Hey, I'm gonna, my cows are a little thinner."
Well, now you're fighting the winter weather, which increases nutrient requirements of the cattle.
And then the majority of your in utero calf growth is happening the last 60 days of their gestation period.
So you have increased requirements for the calf, you have winter weather, and so you're kind of fighting a lot of battles.
Right now is your chance to put good condition on cattle if they're coming in a little thin.
- Always thinking and planning ahead.
- [Sam] Yes, absolutely.
- Georgia, when you were kind of telling us what you do, you mentioned like remote sensing and satellites.
Tell us more about that and how it's used in range monitoring.
- Yeah, so there's a lot of ways that satellite-based information is used to better understand rangelands.
At this foundation, we as scientists or people that use these data will take these collections of images that have been collected from space, from agencies like the US Geologic Survey or sometimes the European Space Station or other sources, and use that to sort of then develop maps generally of vegetation cover or production.
And then that gives us a lot of, you know, opens up the door for more questions after that.
So the main way that these data are made is that we have these collections of images from space and we usually have some sort of local or field information from trained individuals that go out and collect standardized metrics like vegetation cover or vegetation production.
And then we train a model that is able to take these images and take what we know to be true from being out on the ground and then kind of expand our field knowledge by predicting out those same attributes over space and time.
So there's a lot of really great advantages to having this information.
One of the big ways that it covers over the extent of the satellite imagery has a broad range over space and time.
And so if you have an event that occurs that you didn't know was going to happen, like a wildfire, you can have some information of what the vegetation looked like beforehand if you didn't have the opportunity to go out and take measurements in that area because you didn't know a fire was going to occur.
It also has a lot of power for us to be able to look about at variability across space.
So, rangelands are very diverse.
I think people, even when you drive around, you see different patches and clumps of vegetation and you could think about how that, it's hard to make any broad statements and rules when there's so much variability.
And so satellite data is one way that we can look at this variability and see not just overall from a snapshot of a field visit, which is really important, but looking over maybe a whole landscape or over a decade or two decades how the vegetation is changing.
- When you look at the satellite data, are there certain aspects that you can model with pretty good accuracy?
I mean, we were talking earlier about like forage growth.
Are there other things that maybe are really good with satellite?
- Yeah, there's definitely certain things that are easier to model than others.
One common thing that's modeled is herbaceous production or net primary productivity.
So we have a pretty good understanding of how plants grow with a certain amount of sunlight.
And so we can take essentially information about how they reflect light and how much is absorbed and then use our knowledge to then model how they grow and how much has grown throughout the year.
So, pretty good at that and better understanding what we call functional groups of plants, so trees versus shrubs versus grasses.
Generally those broad categories are okay.
Getting more specific to individual species can be tough.
I think if you're trying to think of an individual grass species in a sea of grass, that can be hard to pick out.
And it changes throughout the year as well.
So sometimes plants look more similar to each other than other times in the year.
So throughout the year as things get more dry, then that can be harder to kind of parse those groups out.
But yeah, generally production, cover in these broad groups, there's some better information about height, but taking some of the production information to the next step of what is actually available forage is still, I think, kind of actively being researched and developed.
So definitely a lot of space and people will also make kind of custom models for individual species, like people do that with invasive annual grasses to better understand if there's a certain species that people care a lot about and really want to understand, then we can put more resources and usually have to gather a lot more field data to better train those, yeah.
- Great, and I'm guessing, Georgia, that you could look at management effects, like you mentioned invasive annual grasses.
So if there were large-scale treatments that went down, you could use this technology to get a sense of how well it worked across big landscapes.
- Yeah, definitely.
Yeah, there's a lot of strength in being able to look back in time and then over space for if we have good records of where management was from the federal agencies.
It's public record where these are, but if folks on their own private land have good history of where they've gone out and done certain activities, you can see it from space, which is encouraging.
It's nice to be able to push the needle in that way.
- Yeah, yeah, great.
Okay, Eric, we're just going to get this question out there because it wouldn't be "Montana Ag Live" without a question for an ag economist about the Farm Bill.
- [Eric] Oh, yeah, the Farm Bill.
- This question came in from Billings.
With the recent election results, when should we expect to see the next Farm Bill?
Tell us what you think.
- Yeah, well, so with the recent election, the leadership should be changing in January.
And so I think there is a bit of pressure for the current leadership to push the Farm Bill through, which could be good news for farm groups who want to see a Farm Bill finished.
Because then once you get new leadership, you don't quite know.
And not only that, but really the leadership, there's quite a bit of movement in people within the ag committees themselves.
So I don't think there's too many details in the Farm Bill that need to be ironed out.
I think really just the ag committees need to find their time on the floor to get votes and kind of move forward.
So I would project that it would be done fairly soon, but I've always thought it was going to be done sooner than it actually is.
- When was it supposed to be done?
- Oh, so the last one was signed in 2028.
So it expired a couple years ago and it's.
- 2018?
- 2018, yeah.
(group laughs) 2018, yeah.
- Back to the future.
- Wouldn't that be nice?
- 2018, yeah.
Signed under Donald Trump, but the first term.
And so yeah, we've been on a couple of annual extensions that have kind of pushed things forward.
And one of the interesting things about the Farm Bill process is a lot of the mechanisms that used to be triggered when a new one wasn't signed have kind of been blocked, which if you think about really disturbing farmers when it doesn't get passed, that's kind of good because now if it doesn't get signed, it means we don't see this dairy cliff and some of the other things that we would have seen in the past.
In 2014, there was a story when some of our livestock insurance programs expired and that was really problematic.
And so a lot of those continue on, crop insurance, everything kind of continues on.
And so it sort of lessened the penalties, I guess, for the Senate and the House not getting them through.
But when you hear the leadership in both the House and the Senate committees talk, they want to get it done as fast as they can.
So this might give some momentum to getting that done.
- Nina, this is great because you are the potato woman.
- [Nina] All right, see if I can remember anything.
- And there's already a couple questions from our viewers about potatoes.
- [Nina] Wonderful.
- So the first, I'll kind of group them together or I'll give you the first one and then we'll ask the second one.
This one comes in from Great Falls.
Are there any disease problems or unique challenges with planting potato seeds instead of tubers?
And can you do that?
Are there potato seeds?
- Yes, there are.
That's actually a great question.
So potatoes, I don't know if you ever noticed in your garden, potatoes do flower and they'll produce a little berry and the berry looks kind of like a tiny little tomato, but it always stays green.
And there are seeds inside of there.
And there's actually been a big push in recent years to actually breed potato varieties that can be propagated from true seed.
So you absolutely can grow potatoes from them, but in order to really get any kind of a crop from them, you would need to almost treat them, especially in Montana, like a tomato or a pepper.
And you would want to grow that plant in the greenhouse and get a transplant about eight to 10 inches tall, plant that into the soil.
And then by the end of the season, you will actually have potatoes.
And interestingly enough, there's actually a push to do that, to get more genetically uniform potatoes that have very, very specific traits, whether they be disease resistance or specific nutrient qualities that are actually beneficial.
And it's called diploid breeding.
And they're producing these potatoes that will initially be produced from potato seed, but ultimately those potatoes actually may end up being propagated vegetatively because we do have the infrastructure in place to do vegetatively produced potatoes.
And then also your yield potential is always going to be a lot higher when you start with a two to four ounce seed potato piece versus a seed.
- Yeah, so it sounds like you can do it, but it's quite a bit more work.
- Yeah, yeah, it is.
But for a home garden, I would actually absolutely encourage it because I think it could be a lot of fun.
And there are some that are marketed that when you do harvest potato seed, unless they are like the specific diploid varieties that I'm talking about, they're very genetically diverse.
So like in one berry, you might have different genotypes or different types of potatoes that you grow from that.
So you could plant 20 seeds and you might get 20 different looking type potatoes.
- [Jane] That sounds like fun.
- That actually could be fun.
- Yeah, especially if you're retired.
- Exactly.
(group laughs) Exactly.
Yeah, I need to do that.
I need to add that to my list of things that I want to grow.
- Well, let's get this other potato question out there.
This is from Helena.
How can you avoid scabby looking potatoes?
- So scab is probably one of the biggest banes of every home gardener.
And also depending on where you're growing potatoes, it can also be a big problem for potato producers.
But there are some interesting things about scab.
One is that you actually promote scab by adding a lot of compost or manure to your soil.
So it's kind of counterintuitive because that usually reduces diseases.
So, that's one factor.
Another factor at times can be acidic soils.
We don't have a lot of acidic soils in Montana and we have a lot of scabs.
So those two don't always necessarily go together.
But another factor that I think is the most important one that you can actually modify in your garden is trying to keep your potatoes evenly moist throughout the season.
So my husband and I have actually gone to watering a small amount every day or every other day with drip irrigation to keep even moisture in the soil.
And what that's doing, the bacteria that causes scab is actually not even really a good pathogen.
It basically produces toxins as it's growing on the surface of the potato and that causes the little blisters that cause scab.
And if you can create the conditions that promote a lot of other beneficial bacteria, and that comes with having good moisture, you can reduce the scab.
Another research project that I was involved in many, many years ago with Barry Jacobson, we were looking at some different bio controls for scab and we were growing them on oatmeal or oats.
And when we put the control in the soil, we actually found that we did get a reduction in scab.
And so by putting something in there like oatmeal, and I actually do that sporadically, but you're providing a food source for some beneficial bacteria that could reduce the bacteria, the bad bacteria that are growing on the surface of the potato.
- There's a whole ecosystem down there.
- There's a whole ecosystem.
- Fighting it out, right?
- Exactly, exactly.
- Yeah.
- Survival of the fittest.
- It is, yeah.
This next question that came in is actually, it's actually about, it's a weed question.
- [Nina] You got it, you got it.
- I'm going to take it.
I was on a couple weeks ago and talked about common buckthorn.
And I will say since that show, I've had like four or five calls from viewers that wanted to talk more about common buckthorn.
So, thank you so much.
This person is calling from Billings and they want to know if they cut the branches of their buckthorn, what can you add to the branches to keep them from growing back because it is a re-sprouter.
So what you want to do is cut those branches close to the surface of the ground and immediately brush them with a herbicide.
You could use something that contains imazapyr or glyphosate and you want to do it right after you cut and that'll keep them from re-sprouting.
So there you go.
Here's a question from Billings for Sam.
The caller has heard that cows are now being fed longer to increase their weight when going to market.
He wants to know what the average weight is of, the average weight of cattle now compared to previous years.
And then what percentage of a cow's weight actually becomes meat in the grocery store?
- Jane, Ann's going to kill me.
(group laughs) - [Georgia] A meat scientist.
(panel chatters indistinctly) - Is there a phone a friend?
- That's not an option on this show.
- Eric might know that from the marketing.
- Yeah, maybe Eric can help with that.
- Yeah, I can give you some information and then I'm sure between Eric and I, we can piece something together.
But yeah, it is true that we're increasing days on feed.
That is increasing weight, but more so I think what we're after is increasing quality.
So we're harvesting a higher percentage of prime animals instead of choice by keeping them on.
And so when you think of like the growth cycle of beef cattle, especially in the feed lot, they put on muscle really, really well and really quickly and a pretty good efficiency of doing that.
And they're a little less efficient on putting on fat.
It takes longer.
And so to increase that marbling or that intermuscular fat and that fat coverage, they're keeping them on longer.
That is increasing weight.
I don't know that I could give you a hard and fast number on that.
I know that there are plenty of folks out there that are harvesting steers that are 1,600 pounds or so.
Back in the day, I would say we're probably closer to that 12, maybe 14.
So I mean, they are getting heavier.
And then our typical conversion rate I think is 60%.
So in terms of once that animal's harvested to what is carcass and available for different cuts.
- That was great, yeah.
I'll just add onto that too.
I think it's been fascinating over the last two years to watch what processors have been doing.
And I think a lot of it's economically driven where you have fewer animals coming through the system and just sky high prices and they're high when we look at cow calf prices in Montana, but then also all the way to the retail sector, they're pretty high.
So yeah, we've seen weight go up.
I want to say like the dressed weight's gone up by like 10%, but like 80 pounds in the last couple years, which is like a huge jump.
It's like Sam was saying, it's partly feeding those animals to put on weight.
There's some new beta agonist technologies too maybe that help put it on faster.
Is that?
- Yeah, well, I think there's that, but I think, I guess this is a little bit of a side piece of this, but to get back to the economics of why and part of the reason is that the premiums for a higher quality animal outweighs the discounts of having to do additional trim or some of these larger animals.
So it used to be that you were discounted pretty heavily if your cattle were going through too heavy or too big or too fat, but now your premiums that you're getting for a higher percentage of prime animals are more than outweighing that discount.
- [Eric] Yeah.
- So do you think any of that also might be influenced by the increased use of that trim, like the fat for biofuels and also tallow?
- Yeah.
- Like we're eating tallow, putting it on our skin, that kind of thing, that the trim has become more valuable?
- I don't know any numbers on that.
I don't know if Eric does, but I can say that I have heard many people that are kind of almost frustrated with that in a sense because they used to be able to go to the local meat shop or market and just get beef trim for free, and they just give it and then they'd render it themselves for their own tallow production, and now they're having to purchase that.
So tallow has created a market.
It is growing in popularity.
I don't know anything about numbers and economics of that.
- Yeah, well, and I know that on the processing side, one of the challenges that they're facing is just less animals.
They're very high margin businesses.
And so I think especially those byproducts that come out, those are really kind of volume based.
So the volumes have been dropping.
My guess is, and you mentioned some of the demands for those products have been going up, probably the supply has been shrinking for some of those at the same time.
And so one of the things in Ag Econ that's interesting, at least thinking about this, is the cow-calf producers, their ability to kind of change their production due to higher prices is really hard.
We use the word elastic demand.
I feel like I've used that a few times on this show, but you look at downstream, some of the meat processors, they are able to kind of move some stuff and whether it's heavier weights, I mean, corn's still fairly cheap, so keeping animals on feed a little longer is not that expensive.
And so yeah, the economics of their ability to kind of move and kind of do more with less animals has been interesting to watch.
But it also just puts that higher price then comes back to Montana ranchers because the more weight they're putting on those animals at the end and the bigger premiums they're getting, then the more premiums that cow-calf producers are going to get here back in Montana.
- Eric, there's a question here that came up that may or may not be related to what we're talking about right now because I don't know what BRAND livestock endorsement is, but this person from Great Falls wants to know what is known about the BRAND livestock endorsement that Secretary Rollins announced a couple months back?
Is that related at all?
- Yeah, it is, it is related, yeah.
I mean, I think the decrease in cattle numbers has kind of prompted some policy initiatives and this is one of them, the BRAND endorsement, which stands for some things, but.
(group laughs) - [Nina] It makes a good acronym.
- We won't hold you responsible for remembering what the acronym is.
- The main idea is when you decide to expand your herd, you're effectively holding animals back and you're taking on extra risk when you do that, right?
Because instead of selling them for these record high prices, you're holding them back with the hopes of selling more animals in the future.
And so the brand endorsement gets at, well, could you do that?
And then could you buy, it looks to me, we haven't seen the details on it, but it looks to me kind of like a put option of when you would be selling it to kind of guard against if prices go down, then it would be kind of an insurance policy against that.
So just kind of really basically if you're thinking about holding back some animals and you like that 330 price that they're seeing right now, then maybe you can kind of lock in on maybe $3.
So then if the market goes down to like 250, then at least you'd receive an insurance payment against that difference.
- [Jane] Okay, okay.
- [Eric] Well, and your question was what's happened to it?
I guess it was announced a few months ago.
- Yeah.
- I think we're still waiting for some of the details on it, but it's supposed to be related to the Livestock Risk Protection Insurance Program, which is already out there.
- Okay, okay, thank you.
Georgia, this is a fun question and you can take a shot at it and then it's possible Sam might have to help you with it.
This is good.
This is a call from Butte.
This person said that she's been told years ago that if you look at satellite photos of grazing land, cows always face north when grazing.
She wants to know if this is true.
(group laughs) This is fun.
- I have no idea.
For some context, I guess the normal sets of images that I look at are either 30 meter spatial resolution, so you get one image for 30 meters square.
So that's like the inside of a baseball diamond is about 30 by 30 meters.
And so you kind of get, if you were to really zoom in, it's very pixelated, which still when you zoom out and you look across landscapes, you can see a lot, but I do not see individual cows in those photos.
- [Jane] Okay, Sam, any thoughts on that?
- Maybe Sam does, the drone?
- Yeah, I mean, I don't think so.
(group laughs) - [Jane] It's interesting.
- Yeah.
- Now you have to look back at all the cows you've ever seen grazing.
- Yeah, I'm going to have to go through all our GPS collar data and stuff.
But I think there are some classic examples that in the summertime, cattle may prefer north-facing slopes where it's a little cooler, where grass is a little greener later.
In the winter time, they prefer south-facing slopes, things like that.
You will see things like cows will graze into the wind.
So they're not sitting there perpendicular catching all that wind and cooling body temperature.
So they do a lot of interesting things.
From satellite imagery, most of the stuff I've, I mean, I've even worked with like 10-meter resolution, but even then it's really hard to find a cow.
You just see a black dot, if anything.
So, I don't know.
I don't know on that.
There is a chance too that if you did have fine enough resolution that you captured cattle on on that picture, like how often do they, like if you're thinking like, say, Google Earth or something like that, they don't necessarily update that every day.
So it could be that you saw the cows grazing facing in a northern direction and then that map wasn't necessarily open and you saw it months later and they're still there grazing north.
I've seen that where an airplane was caught in the satellite imagery and it was there for a year and a half.
(group laughs) But yeah, so it could be, it kind of depends on the system you're looking at, but I see cows graze different directions for different reasons.
- Georgia, in the work that you do, do you have to make corrections for anything about the intervals between images?
- Yeah, the main thing is we call that revisit time.
So you could think of it as how often the satellite's going around space and taking a picture.
And so yeah, it depends on what you're looking at.
So if you're looking for images during the growing season, you may kind of select four sets of images within there.
What I more frequently have to do is remove photos with a lot of clouds.
That's a bigger issue.
So one example is I'm doing some work now looking at vegetation recovery after prescribed fires.
And in south of Montana, those are often in the spring, which is a cloudy time.
And so if you're trying to find, which I am, trying to find a photo before the fire and after the fire to do a difference between those two images to get at things like fire severity, it can be hard to find images that have not too many clouds in them.
There's different filters and kind of criteria that you have to use.
And then also if there's some clouds, it can kind of scatter the beams of light, essentially, and kind of fuzz out the photo in some ways.
And so there's many people have thought about this for a while of how to filter and select for, but it is still sometimes a persistent problem.
If you're looking for like, I need a June 15th image of this spot, if there's a cloud that's over that thing when the satellite passes, then you have a picture of a cloud, essentially.
But you hope that you get enough sets of images that you get some good ones without clouds.
- One thought that could get to the viewer's question though is that cows are creatures of habit, if you will.
And a lot of times, they will graze down towards water.
Say they'll graze, they go to water, then they will loaf around and then they go back up and graze in the afternoon.
And it could be that just when the satellite is coming through or when the producer or the individual is looking at it, they just happen to catch them as they're funneling to water every time.
And so that could very well seem like they're going the same direction every time if it just happens to be at the same time when they're on the same behavioral trajectory of whatever it is they're doing, whether they're going to water or away from water or how that works.
- That's interesting.
Nina, here's a question for you.
This is coming in from Great Falls.
The person is wondering about kind of the pros and cons of tilling the garden at the end of the season or maybe waiting to do that till spring.
- So in many situations, it's beneficial to get it tilled in the fall, especially if you had any clods or anything.
Over the winter, you're going to get freezing and thawing which is going to break up any clods.
If you've got a lot of organic matter, maybe you're going to be putting it to bed in a really nice, even well-tilled situation where you've got kind of nice, fluffy till.
But if you don't get it done in the fall, don't despair.
You can get it done in the spring.
Sometimes that can be a little bit more of a challenge just because it's wetter and if you have heavy soils, a lot of times that will make it a little bit more challenging to just get it tilled with the wet soil.
But yeah, I mean if you need to do your cleanup and tilling in the spring, that's just fine.
- [Jane] All is not lost.
- All is not lost, no.
- Well, if the mild fall holds on, probably get out and do it now.
- Actually tomorrow would be a really good time if you have the opportunity because I think Tuesday, we've got like a 95% chance of rain, or at least in Bozeman.
But I think a lot of places of the state is going to get a little rainy on Tuesday.
- But staying pretty mild as far as I know.
Here's a question.
I like this question.
I mean, I like all the questions, right?
So this is about rangeland and carbon credits.
And I was reading a little bit before the show that globally speaking, like rangeland contains 20% of the world's carbon.
So I'm wondering maybe, I don't know, I'll throw it out there for Georgia and maybe Eric.
Are naturally occurring rangelands eligible for carbon credits?
- I would say if you've made improvements, they probably are eligible for carbon credits.
I'm not the expert here, but we had Dr.
Kelsey Larson at our annual Outlook conference spoke on this of kind of what things to look for if you are interested in the carbon credit market.
And I think for Montana, the people who seem to be the most interested in it are rangeland producers because that is where the opportunities are.
I don't think the credits are huge, but if you have a lot of areas, maybe it could make sense.
- [Nina] Are there some privately traded carbon credits?
- Mm-hmm, yeah, I mean that's where a lot of them end up going is kind of these third-party companies that are going to sell them.
I noticed on my airline ticket it says what the carbon footprint is and you can pay a little extra if you want to offset that.
And my guess is that's kind of where the offsets go.
So yeah, there are companies and I wish I could have them in mind, but I would say Dr.
Larson is probably the person to reach out to who's done some work in that area.
- Yeah, and I guess I'll just add, I think one thing that's interesting when you're thinking about carbon and rangeland is it's above-ground carbon but also especially deep-rooted perennial bunch grasses are pretty good at storing carbon below ground too.
So that's a big strength, but also harder to measure when you're thinking about quantifying it in terms of credits.
- Can you measure stored, like soil carbon with remote sensing?
- Yes, yes.
I don't do it as much personally, but especially when you're thinking of above-ground net primary productivity and how that's translated, there are some models that are estimating below-ground carbon primarily using a lot of soils and field data and information and informed by what the above-ground plant community is like.
- So it's more focused on the above-ground plant community.
- My understanding of it is that it is, yes.
And there's a little bit of soil parent material considerations.
- One of the conversations I heard once about rangeland and carbon credits is that in some ways, those programs reward maybe people who have degraded rangeland that they can make changes in their grazing management.
So in some ways, they're getting rewarded where people who are currently managing their rangeland very well and have very healthy rangeland, there isn't a reward system for them.
- Yes, I think that's a common complaint is that you can show a big increase from a more degraded site to a more improved site, but if you've been doing your best for a long time and it's not as degraded, that's harder to show an impact.
And it's also, it's just hard to know how responsive carbon credits in the soil are to things like grazing management changes.
So I think it's more of an open question of how things like virtual fence and other adaptive grazing practices impact soil carbon.
- Yeah, well in economics, we have a term for that.
What you don't want to do is to sort of nudge someone in the direction of maybe doing something that they would have done without the nudge.
So that's kind of where the nudge is the hope of like, I wouldn't do this but for the, and our term is positive externality.
If it creates a benefit for wildlife or for rangeland or water systems that goes kind of just beyond the ranch that maybe they don't internalize, but then that nudge is kind of what they need to do that practice.
And so yeah, but I definitely talk to a lot of people who are like, well, I've been doing it that way for 20 years.
Sorry.
- Yeah, Georgia, you mentioned virtual fencing.
We've had a couple questions about virtual fencing.
We'll just start with this one from Hysham.
Can virtual fence actually save time and money on a cow-calf operation, or is it still too early for most producers to adopt it?
So I don't know if maybe Sam and Eric take a stab at that.
- Yeah, I actually travel the state and I do tons of talks on virtual fence.
In terms of precision technology and livestock production systems, virtual fence is probably the most talked about in route going.
So I'll throw out a couple of things.
So I know for a lot of these virtual fence companies, believe it or not, Montana is one of their top markets in the United States.
So it's a real hotbed for a lot of these companies.
There's a lot of people in these extensive systems that are utilizing it.
In my talks, I specifically say that this is a ranch by ranch scenario.
So I can't make a general statement to say, "Hey, virtual fence is going to be economically feasible for everybody."
Where I see it playing a larger role in ranches are folks that were, there's ranches out there that would, say, hire somebody every summer that did nothing but move electric fences to strip graze across a field or something like that.
And these virtual fences can do that from your phone versus having somebody out there.
So the other places I've heard of where it's been really beneficial is where you have these pastures where it is difficult to get animals to distribute to different parts of the pasture.
And by utilizing virtual fence, and I say this with a little bit of caution because we need to be careful about how we move these animals, but we can increase some AUMs strictly just off of forage availability from places that the cows wouldn't go otherwise that we can now move them across.
So those systems, where you're ready to make a change or you're ready to do something, it can be incredibly beneficial.
I have seen folks who just want strictly a containment system.
They don't really care about the management per se.
I'm not sure virtual fence is probably the best option for those guys because the real nuts and bolts behind it is the flexibility and management.
You have those animals' GPS.
Most of these systems now have algorithms built in that are actually tracking some animal behavior issues, let you know if animals aren't moving the way that they should be or an animal is either down or hasn't moved for multiple hours.
So either that animal's collar had fallen off or that animal is down and probably needs to be evaluated.
And so there are some added benefits that folks are seeing as well.
- Well, the first thing you mentioned, it seems like there could be some good labor saving technology there.
Like, have you seen that I guess in the ranches you've worked with where you just don't need to hire the same number of people to manage?
- I'm a big proponent of agriculture and keeping people in agriculture, so I try not to say, "Hey, you cannot hire people."
But I'm also a realist in some of the sense that finding labor in agriculture is difficult.
And so if you got the perfect system and you got the people in place to do what you need to do, that's great.
If you're one of those guys that's just really struggling to find somebody to come out, I mean those are two different things.
But I try to frame it more as in now you can take this position and distribute what, their labor to other things that may be important to the ranch other than just moving fences or moving cattle.
- So I have a question.
So my family ranches in central Montana right on the edge of the Missouri Breaks and one of the big challenges there are the bulls.
And they have a tendency to go deep into the breaks and sometimes you can find them and sometimes you can't.
And one of the things that they've talked about is if they could GPS their bulls, but one of the things they're concerned about is collaring a bull because the way they described a bull is like an engorged tick.
Their head is.
- Big neck, small head.
- Big, yeah, neck, small head and keeping a collar on, are there other ways that you can attach a GPS device to an animal?
- Yeah, absolutely.
And so we run into this, a little bit of confusion here and there.
There's things that we call geofencing and things we call virtual fencing.
And the virtual fence is the collar, it's the animal, you drew your line on your phone and the animal goes up to it.
If it doesn't respond to that line, it gets shocked.
It's like an invisible electric fence.
Geofencing is just you have an app on your phone where you have all your fence lines and then that animal's GPS with some unit and then you're tracking that animal.
And if that animal leaves the fence, then you get this notification that, "Hey, this animal's gone.
Here's where it's at."
There is several companies out there that have GPS ear tags.
And I would say if you're just interested in tracking and knowing where a handful of animals are, like bulls, that's probably going to be way more beneficial.
I have heard of folks putting virtual fence on bulls, but that's, like you said, bulls are just harder on everything.
- What about the grazing quality?
Like have you guys, how much, if you're really able to move your cows around to the forage that really is the best, I mean, can you make a big impact on animal growth and your sort of response to drought in the next year with that?
- Yeah, so we've actually have a couple research projects where we're looking at more of the intensity rotation with virtual fence versus like the season long or more of like that continuous grazing.
And yes, you can increase efficiency of moving animals and maybe altering the use of plants across the pasture.
And there's pluses and minuses to that, I'm sure Georgia can talk about.
But from an animal perspective, one thing that I try to tell folks, and this isn't new data, this is data that was generated I think back in the '70s but still applies today, is when we condense animals into a smaller area to do like what we're terming now as adaptive grazing or that high intensity, short duration, what we're reducing is that animal's ability to select for higher quality forage, just more competition.
So they're just eating more generalistically instead of selectively.
Sounds like a great thing.
It can be a beneficial thing, but one thing producers should realize with that is you will likely have a reduced individual animal performance.
And it's strictly a diet quality thing.
- Interesting.
- They're eating a general diet, so they're getting a lower quality diet than an animal that's able to go out and physically select.
Now folks also would suggest that because you're doing the high intensity, short duration moves, you have the potential to have actually an increase in pounds of animal per acre, but in terms of average daily gains per animal, they'll decrease.
So it kind of depends on your system.
If it's a stocker yearling system, we're selling those animals on an individual pounds per animal kind of basis, average daily gain, you want to capitalize on those gains.
A mature cow herd, I'm more interested in that she's maintaining body condition than necessarily putting on a bunch of weight.
So kind of depends.
- [Eric] Yeah, interesting.
- I want to share a couple comments from some of our viewers.
We love when we hear from viewers live while we're filming the show.
Apparently, we have viewers who pay a lot of attention to cattle behavior.
So someone from Thompson Falls says he loves the show, so thank you very much.
He's been watching cows his whole life and has noticed that when they are grazing, they tend to face the same direction and he wasn't sure which direction, but the whole herd is facing the same direction.
And then another caller from Glendive commented that Charolais cattle never seem to lie down in the field.
They're always grazing.
I don't see cattle lying down very much, so that's interesting.
- I would throw that, you can look into like your ruminant ecology and how things adapted to do what.
And that's a big thing about ruminants is that they will go graze and then they'll bed down somewhere else to chew, cud and ruminate.
- Oh interesting.
- That's an adaptive piece that they believe was to escape predation and go out and graze in a short amount of time and then you go and bed down and ruminate somewhere else.
- I want to get to a horticulture question for Nina.
This person is wondering if they plant flower seeds now, will they bloom in the spring?
- I mean, you can speak to this as a weed scientist.
There are groups of plants that are like fall annuals that will germinate in the spring and then over winter.
And so there are some of those that would be in that class in weeds, it's like the mustards and things like that.
I know in terms of, I'm not thinking flowers as much as vegetables, but like spinach, you can plant in the fall and it will come up the next spring.
I don't know as much about flowers.
You can do that with seed and that's probably just maybe like alyssum or something like that, which is a brassica, maybe.
- I think if you have like a wildflower seed mix, now is a great time to put the seed out.
- Yeah, absolutely.
- And yes, it over winters and then will come up in the spring.
- Right, right.
And there are some that actually, yeah, they can come up and even survive the winter as a small seedling, but yeah.
- I have a question here.
I'm going to give it to Georgia because I think she might have some thoughts on this.
This is a call that's come in from Drummond and they're commenting about juniper or like conifer encroachment moving into grasslands.
And are we doing anything about that?
What are our concerns with that?
- Yeah, great question.
It's definitely, definitely a concern.
So this is when we see woodland expansion, sometimes with juniper species, but it could be other species as well.
So that's areas that historically have not supported woodlands, so these large trees, and now primarily due to changing in grazing, but also excluding fire from the system, we have given the trees this opportunity to kind of come in and fill in these spaces and they're good competitors.
And so sometimes they'll end up removing herbaceous species and shrubs from the area and just overall kind of changing the way that these systems work.
And so yeah, it's definitely a big concern for a lot of people and there's a lot of implications for grazing management and wildlife habitat.
So there's a lot of things that people are doing for this.
One main way is they're using mechanical treatments to go in and remove these trees.
So it could be individual level, like going out with a chainsaw and cutting the trees down or using, if it's more trees, a higher density using essentially wood chippers and other like larger masticating equipment.
And that is often paired or followed up with fire.
So generally, the grasses and shrubs will be able to come back better after fire than the trees will.
And that can be a really effective pairing when you have some type of mechanical thinning coming in removing some of these trees, sometimes piling them up, sometimes coming back and then burning the piles.
You can end up catching a lot of these smaller seedlings of trees, which can then kind of be the next generation.
If you think of one parent tree that has many, many baby trees around it, it's really hard with a chainsaw especially or a large rotating head tool to be able to get all those little seedlings, and fire is a good tool to do that.
So yeah, people are definitely working on it.
- Yeah, and my understanding, this person commented specifically about BLM, but my understanding is across federally administered land and private land, there's action occurring with these.
- Yes, I think that's true.
I think there's sometimes different motivating factors that drive people to do those management activities.
But yes, I think there's a lot of activity, especially in Southwest Montana and Eastern Montana, people doing that, yeah.
- Great, thank you, Georgia.
We're getting down to the last couple minutes of the show, so we'll throw some questions out there, kind of like maybe do some rapid fire.
- [Sam] Okay.
- I have to share this one, this is from Billings.
This is for Nina.
The person's been unsuccessful growing Brussels sprouts.
Do you have any advice on how to grow them here?
- I have never been able to successfully grow them in Montana.
I mean, they are like a 110 day vegetable or something like that, or maybe even longer.
And in recent years, they've become really readily available in the grocery store.
- [Jane] Without any bugs.
- Without any bugs, yeah, that's another thing.
Yeah, you've got to control cabbage loopers the entire season long.
So yeah, I mean, I think it can be done, but it is a very long seasoned vegetable.
And by the time they're really going to start producing the Brussels sprouts, I think we're about at the end.
- Yeah, a lot of kids will be happy to hear that this is not a good place to grow Brussels sprouts.
(group laughs) - But it's available in the stores.
- Yeah, exactly.
- We're down to our last minute of the show.
Georgia, just in a real quick, anything you didn't get a chance to say about rangelands that you want to say in just 15, 20 seconds?
- No, I just, yeah, I guess it's been great to be here in Montana and get to explore the diverse rangelands across the state, especially getting to drive around and visit with folks.
So, looking forward to doing more of that.
- Yeah, we're looking forward to all the great work you're going to do here at MSU.
- Yeah.
- So I would like to say thank you to Georgia specifically for being our special guest.
Thank you to the panelists and thank you to our phone answerers tonight.
We didn't get to all the questions, but I do want to thank our viewers for staying with us through the season.
And also like to say a thank you to our funders and the funding supporters for this show.
And please join us in February when we'll start again.
- [Narrator] For more information and resources, visit montanapbs.org/aglive.
(mellow country music) - [Narrator] "Montana Ag Live" is made possible by the Montana Department of Agriculture, MSU Extension, the MSU Ag Experiment Station of the College of Agriculture, the Montana Wheat & Barley Committee, Cashman Nursery & Landscaping, the Gallatin Gardeners Club, and the Montana Federation of Garden Clubs.
(gentle music)
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
New Episode- Drama

Benjamin Wainwright stars as Maigret in the contemporary adaptation of Georges Simenon's novels.

Recently Added
New Episode
New Season





Support for PBS provided by:
Montana Ag Live is a local public television program presented by Montana PBS
The Montana Department of Agriculture, the MSU Extension Service, the MSU AG Experiment Stations of the College of Agriculture, the Montana Wheat & Barley Committee, Cashman Nursery and Landscaping, Gallatin Gardeners Club, and the Montana Foundation of Garden Clubs.
